Thursday, 5 January 2012
Deliver Us From Evil (2006)
‘But if anyone causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a large millstone hung around his neck and be drowned in the depths of the sea’ -- Matthew 18.6
The phrase ‘child sex abuse’ is euphemistic. It understates the nature of what is happening in reality. To not mince words, in most instances, it is rape. For children, the consequences are latent, until they reach maturity and find they cannot have meaningful relationships with others. They have been violated both physically and sexually, by someone they reposed confidence in. Can these victims ever hope to sustain a normal life? The heart-rendering answer appears to be, no. The sins of fathers do appear to be visited upon children most cruelly.
Deliver us from Evil explains the gravity of the clergy sexual abuse epidemic through the story of one delinquent, paedophile priest- Father Oliver O’Grady. During his tenure as priest, O’Grady sexually abused hundreds of children. The film focuses upon the insidious manner in which O'Grady ingratiates himself within the families of his would-be victims, abusing their trust before abusing their sons and daughters. One of the remarkable achievements of director Amy Berg is the candid interviews she is able to obtain with O'Grady. He comes across as an affable man who endeavours to help outcast children and protect them from a cruel world. It is an elaborate deception because he actually believes it himself. But it is nothing more than a coward's pretext for surrounding himself with vulnerable youth who are at his mercy. O'Grady is aware of his attraction to children, even toddlers, but places himself in the path of temptation, knowing he will inevitably yield to it. "It should not have happened" is the only apology O'Grady can provide. The audience may feel appropriately apoplectic upon hearing such a pithy and pathetic confession following the revelation of the complete landscape of his atrocities.
Hearing the stories of Ann Jyono, Nancy Sloan and Adam M and the grief of their parents is a shattering experience. Watching Ann's father discuss the rape of his child, with visible agony flooding his entire being at the thought of it, is excruciating. The impact of O'Grady's actions never recedes into history. They manifest themselves into the present and blight the future of his victims. Ann is getting older, with no prospect of keeping an enduring relationship with a man. Adam M, sodomised brutally by O'Grady, struggles to be intimate with any woman. They are in a state of aborted development. Whilst the perpetrator's life goes on relatively uninhibited.
Equally abominable is the manner in which O'Grady's continual abuse was handled by his superiors in the Catholic Church. Hearing the depositions of Archbishop Mahoney and Monsenior Cain is singularly infuriating. They implemented that morally irreprehensible Vatican policy of trafficking paedophile priests whereby offending priests such as O'Grady are relocated from one parish to another in order to keep them out of the public's eye and ensure the are beyond the jurisdiction of county police. Flanked by crafty lawyers, Mahoney and Cain say little and evade what they can. It is inconceivable that neither knew of O'Grady's violations of canonical and State laws. They shielded him from the authorities for as long as possible. And if the audience felt O'Grady to be a nebulous creature that possessed genuine remorse, such naive hopes are dashed as the documentary reveals the despicable bargain he made with the Catholic Church prior to his trial. When O'Grady was about to take the stand to reveal how his prior offences had been handled by his superiors, the Church struck a last minute agreement with O'Grady. O'Grady was urged to do time in return for an annuity that would ensure he came out of prison well-off enough to look after himself. All whilst the families this man has tormented are financially and psychologically annihilated. Later, O'Grady writes to his victims and asks to meet them so they can all be released from the collective burden of the past. Two weeks later he revokes his offer. O'Grady is willing to accept a diagnosis that he may have a dissociative order. That is a rich concession. No, a more apt prognosis would be that he is an insufferable coward.
'And lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil' says Matthew 6.13. O'Grady sought out temptation and then inflicted evil upon his charges. He walks the streets of Ireland a free man. Whatever may be one's thoughts on religion, believers and non-believers may find common ground in agreeing that this man and his accomplices must be punished in the material world, before their celestial judgment.
Amy Berg sensibly withstands the lure towards meditating on how these crimes relate to the existence or otherwise of God. The spiritual desolation occasioned by abuse has not destroyed the victims' faith (although for one of the parents it has). Instead, Berg presents more nuanced reasons for the widespread culture of sexual abuse prevalent among the Catholic clergy. One possible catalyst suggested by many who have studied the problem is that deleterous practice of celibacy which is never mandated by the Bible (indeed, all of Christ’s apostles except John were married). The sexual immaturity of priests coming out of Canon schools finds sexual parity only in children- who they consider their 'peers'. The more pragmatic and disturbing origins of this practice lies in the desire of the Catholic Church to ensure that the children of priests (particularly sons) could not herit the property of their fathers, thereby leaving it in the welcoming hands of the Church. All religions take particular interest in regulating the affairs of the body. In demonising certain actions and urges, religion unwittingly occasions the perversion such repression produces in those who obey its precepts.
In a film of victims and villains, Father Tom Doyle functions as something of a hero. As a priest for decades and a Canon lawyer, he has fearlessly petitioned the Catholic Church to take steps to redress harm done to victims of clergy abuse and take positive actions in curbing the depravities in its ranks. To this day, the Catholic Church remains paralysed. Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI) bears especial blame in this regard, heading for twenty-four years the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, a branch of the Vatican whose responsibility it is to discipline paedophile priests. But his tenure was one of inaction and in his Pontifical capacity there have been only limited changes to archaic Vatican policies. The Catholic Church's fetish for protecting its reputation from the scourge of sexual abuse has paradoxically inflicted a serious assault on its credibility. This is a pity, for the Catholic Church and its adherents have much to be proud of- from its active role charity work to providing disaster relief assistance. In an interview with Dateline in 2005, Father Tom Doyle said “they ought to sell the Vatican to the Mormons or to Disney or something and go out and start all over again”. Father Doyle explains Catholicism as not being about the faithful venerating the highest echelons of the Vatican and treating the likes of O'Grady as messengers of the divine. The strength of the faith lies in its community with other adherents and fundamental respect for humanity. Deliver us from Evil examines the frightful consequences of ordaining ordinary men with the reflected aura of a superior being.
The John Jay Study in 2004 found an alarming 10,667 individuals since 1950 had made credible allegation of sexual abuse by 4,392 Catholic priests in America. Similar studies have been undertaken in Ireland (consider the astonishing findings of the Murphy Commission), Australia, Canada, Malta and Belgium. They have been consistently damning in their analysis of Catholic institutions and the manner in which allegations are investigated (especially how credible allegations are never required to be reported to law enforcement authorities). Studies have not yet been conducted in Latin America and Africa where the results will almost definitely be even more devastating. The Vatican's apathy, truculence and continual reluctance in confronting the institutionalised culture of child sex abuse in spite of the cavalcade of information finding its way into public consciousness bears remembering. William Wilberforce enunciated that great test for moral culpability for the evils of others when he said, "You may choose to look the other way but you can never say again that you did not know". The Holy See saw and it looked away. Deliver us from Evil is essential viewing.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



No comments:
Post a Comment