Saturday, 17 December 2011
In Memoriam: Christopher Hitchens (1949-2011)
To succinctly divine the nature of Christopher Hitchens is an insurmountable task. The closest I can come is to say he was himself wholly (to brutishly quote 'A View from the Bridge')- he followed where his reason led him and created himself in the image of no man before him. He was his own man, married to neither the left nor right of politics, nor to what was comfortable or polite. I cannot confess to having read Hitchens' works, or even his most famous works. What I have read has broadened my mind, exposed it to the limitless possibilities of the unexplored and given credence to what I have always felt to be that instinctively correct approach to morality- humanism. Stretched beyond those original dimensions by Hitchens' writing, my mind "can never regain its original dimensions".
What struck me first about Hitchens was the sheer wealth of knowledge at his fingertips. He had a literary reference for every point he wished to impart. He was, as he described himself, an "insufferable intellectual". He devoured books on anything and everything. His eruditeness could be easily mistaken for intellectual arrogance, but I believe it stemmed from his love of literature and language. The man read prolifically- why deny him the fruits of his labour? His collection of essays in 'Arguably' (2011) traverses across just about every known terrain from politics to literature to social commentary and of course, religion. I would not be surprised if he remembered everything he read and his encyclopaedic knowledge of literature, no matter how obscure, always found cause to escape his grasp. I often wonder the benefits of being so well read or knowing so much about the world. What use is that knowledge? I believe it has instrinsic value and for some, positively amounts to a hobby. But more importantly, it opens our minds to new ideas and new ways of looking upon familiar situations. So we excavate through ancient literature and travel the nether regions of sad States to find something- some semblance of truth that we can take back with us, that could provide some solution to an immediate or distant dilemma. I believe it is almost a duty too, being fundamentally empathetically, we are wired to consume knowledge about how others behave, the worlds they inhabit and the troubles that confront them. Hitchens walked thousands of miles in thousands of people's boots and he catalogued his experiences for those of us who lack that courage to do so. To dedicate one's life to such a pursuit is hardly ignoble.
Hitchens was a polemic and a contrarian. This meant he had enemies. He cultivated a healthy hatred among his opponents because he was not afraid to argue his cause. I am increasingly of the opinion that to make any imprint on this world, you need to ruffle feathers rather consistently. But Hitchens was relentless. He did not simply defeat his opponents, as Martin Amis said, Hitchens destroyed them. He could not stand stupidity and would no let an absurd or bigoted statement go unattended. Those who he frequently took aim at included the royal family, Mother Teresa and Henry Kissinger. But his most stinging rebuke would be reserved for religion. Hitchens was not one for the melodrama but I think he sincerely saw religion as a threat that endangered a free and tolerant society- an assault to the steady progress of civilisation. As I make my way through 'God is Not Great' (2007), I feel overwhelmed by his near-oppressive reasoning. I believe his derision of religion stems from the affront the latter causes to what Hitchens treasures most in this world- the right to think independently. Hitchens' reverence of Thomas Paine's 'The Rights of Man' could not brook the intellectual vacuum that is the prerequisite of all religions. Many of what religion teaches us, we could arrive at by ourselves. We innately know the evils of murder, genocide and theft. We needed no Ten Commandments or Koran or Gita. To say we did would concede a horrific and untrue vision of human behaviour, that we would all be immoral fiends killing and pillaging ourselves into extinction if we had no scripture to guide us. Hitchens was in a way militantly atheist, but only because the times needed it. The ability of the non-believer to live peaceably amongst believers is becoming increasingly difficult- we have religious maniacs flying planes into buildings, suicide bombings, reciprocal violence and the inherent need of even the most amicable religions to proselytise. Hitchens would have loved a world not governed by religion, but he was always prepared to allow proponents of faith to "play with their toys" so long as they did not make him or his children play with those toys. On hearing that Hitchens had been diagnosed with oesophageal cancer, cruel religious zealots cheered that Hitchens had got what was coming. Some prayed for his recovery. Hitchens wanted neither of it. He would not abandon his belief on his deathbed and turn hypocrite to his principled values, for it would be cowardly and false.
Above all, Hitchens was an advocate of freedom. Freedom of thought, conscience, speech and sexuality. The denial of such rights almost inevitably stemmed from prejudice or a self-serving motive. I would be safe to say that he would agree with the proposition that given a choice between freedom and servitude, the people would choose the former. He saw dogmatic faiths as the antithesis of freedom because they necessarily stunted free thought, requiring adherence to a completed theory. Hitchens championed his values at every occasion, from defending his friend Salman Rushdie's 'The Satanic Verses' and knighthood to the more questionable war in Iraq. Whilst in principle I would agree with Hitchens that the overthrow of the Saddam regime is desirable, it is incongruous with the Western world's former tolerance of the equally vile Gaddafi regime, the Mugabe regime and the ever-rising threat of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Many pieces about Hitchens note his split from the left to more staunch right-winged perspectives. I do not see it so. I think his views on Iraq, and more broadly the threat to civilisation posed by religious fundamentalism was fomenting for some time, at least since the fatwa was issued against Rushdie by the opportunistic Ayatollah Khomeini. Hitchens is far too reasonable to follow ideology. He analyses situations on a case by case basis using the strength of his logic and experience. To brand the man with a dreary cast of neocon or Marxist is to diminish his worth and his legacy.
It is not that Hitchens is simply one of the best proponents of the English language I've read that makes him so compelling. It's that he is just so damn engaging and interesting. Reading Hitchens is a delight because his works are a treasure trove of fascinating history and literature. Benjamin Franklin was an atheist, Madison believed the requirement for chaplains in the army to be incompatible with the First Amendment, the only Nazi to be excommunicated by the Catholic Church was Goebbles (not for Nazi atrocities but because he married a Protestant), Wodehouse's childlike innocence oozing delightfully into his prose as well as dazzling essays on Bill Clinton, Saul Bellow, Mark Twain, George Orwell and countless others some of whom he admired intensely and others who faced ideological laceration at the hands of his keystrokes. I look forward to reading Hitchens' memoir, Hitch-22, because his life has taken such an unusual and unpredictable trajectory. His generous mother who would later commit suicide with her lover and his upright Naval father must have galvanised Hitchens' characters. His astuteness and passion for the language was also furthered as a consequence of the company he kept- Salman Rushie, Martin Amis, Ian McEwen among others. To his last day, Hitchens was writing and reading, his hospital room filled with books (with notes characteristically scribbled along the margins) as if to ward off the inconvenience of illness and boredom. A life time of inquiring and learning left Hitchens with the one fact he knew to be most certain- that nothing is certain. That the surest path to that correct decision is through the exercising of reason.
Like him or hate him, Hitchens exudes genuine charisma. He speaks in that persistent and wildly witty way that made people listen. That sly grin and sense of irony never left him. He could insult his critics like no other. He discerned and harpooned the ridiculous, the inane and the hateful. The folly of the reasoned lot of society is they are far too reasonable. They rarely speak out with veracity. But Hitchens did, because it was not only his prerogative but in a way, he must have felt it his duty. Hitchens' mother, whom he deeply adored, told him the greatest sin one can make is to be boring. That he never was. He travelled endlessly, met people and placed himself in the vicinity of turning points in history (ie. the overthrow of the military junta in Greece). He chronically smoked and drank himself into oblivion. He regretted none of that. But then again, Hitchens stood alone. What I admire most about Hitchens is that he walked his own path. He had no use for sentimentality and had the courage to stand firmly by his ideals. At his core, I sincerely believed he wanted to leave this place a little better off- though he would never admit to such a banal aspiration. Looking back through the writings of history and his experiences abroad, he must have felt dumbfounded by the absurdity and cruelty of the world today. He rebelled against our own failures and against our apathy. In doing so, he made a difference. How rarely we can say that of anyone.
His friend, Ian McEwen said of Hitchens most appropriately, "if Hitchens didn't exist, we wouldn't be able to invent him". Christopher Hitchens did not subscribe to that comforting thought of life after death. So I will avoid saying anything as trite as 'rest in peace'. But Hitchens has attained a more meaningful immortality. In the words he dedicated his life to and the nobler ideas he so eloquently espoused, he is forever alive. Thank you, Mr. Hitchens.
Monday, 12 December 2011
Letters from Iwo Jima (2006)
There were twenty-two thousand Japanese soldiers stationted on the volcano island of Iwo Jima when the American's commenced 'Operation Detachment' in 1945. It was a battle the Japanese knew they could not win. No reinforcements would be sent by Japanese headquarters- no air support would be forthcoming and no navel force would come to their aid. Being an island, they had nowhere to retreat to. By the end of it, there would only be about two hundred Japanese survivors, the rest dying in a futile battle or having committed ritual suicide. But a fight that should have lasted only a day was prolonged by the resilient and courageous Japanese soldiers into a thirty-six day vicious battle where seven thousand Americans would also perish.
Clint Eastwood’s companion piece to Flags of our Fathers (2006) tells the Battle of Iwo Jima from the Japanese perspective. It is a perspective at stark odds with the American one. The Americans expected to return home from the battle whilst the Japanese knew they would not. What goes through the mind of condemned men? Eastwood attempts to answer the question. For men of the Showa period, it was honourable to die for the Emperor. Best die than return having failed or end up in enemy hands. Not all the characters in Iwo Jima see it so, but too many did, making Iwo Jima an enduring monument to misplaced nationalism and deity-like worship of Emperor Hirohito.
The film opens with General Kuribayashi (Ken Watanabe) arriving on the ill-fated island. He stops the men digging trenches on the beach and instead has them to building tunnels. This battle would be fought underground. Into the rocks of Iwo Jima, the Japanese built 1500 rooms which were connected by over 16 miles of tunnels. The plan was brazen and revolutionary. “This one is trouble” observes Admiral Ohsugi of Kuribayashi. Each Japanese soldier is required to take ten American lives before they have the temerity to die himself. Under the leadership of the brilliant Kuribayashi, the American victory would be hard-earned and costly.
Beside the battle-hardened General Kuribayashi, Iwo Jima follows the story of Saigo (Kazunari Ninomiya), a baker who is the latest to be conscripted by the Japanese government, who are increasingly running out of their usual pool of candidates. The scene where his pregnant wife receives the letter demanding his immediate assimilation into the Army is beautifully done. For a moment, the veil of misguided patriotism is shed for the realities of the life a woman who is likely to become a widow. Saigo is intuitive, smart and brave where necessary. He sees the futility of the fight. He has arrived at the conclusion that war is rarely an honour business, his friend having died of “honourable dysentery”. Unlike his brethen, he fights not to die for his country, but to die meaningfully for his country, if he must die at all.
As he researched Flags of our Fathers, Clint Eastwood became fascinated by the man leading the Japanese against the American soldiers, General Kuribayashi. The idea is entirely remarkable, making two films about the same battle, one from each perspective. But we should not be so surprised, the man is a consummate storyteller and this story is worth telling, twice. He succeeds in humanising the enemy, whoever that enemy may be. No film has been attempted on the Japanese side of Iwo Jima. In doing so, he has given the Japanese back some their history. The film is shot in a greying chrome. It adds a layer of antiquity but also drains the imagery of aesthetics. In such colour, the island of Iwo Jima is reduced to a difficult and inhospitable domain. There is no safety there, even the underground caves are under constant threat of collapsing. Perhaps in taking away much of the colour, Eastwood distances us from ignorant notions of good and evil. These are just ordinary men fighting a barbaric war. Duty compels them accept their position, even as disease ravages them, as they survive on a diet of worms and when the water becomes scarce. But they press on, trying to confront the death that awaits them with some dignity.
Making a film in Japanese and working with an all-Japanese cast could not have been easy. The cast is impeccable and each character brings a uniqueness that makes us care about their fate intimately. Ken Watanabe brings a dignified and slightly weary presence to the crucial character of General Kuribayashi. His heart is elsewhere, but his mind is firmly fixed on the task before him. Then we meet Shimizu, who we assume to be one thing, but find something else entirely. His confidante Baron Nishi, an Olympic equestrian, speaks the only English in the film in a poignant scene with an American prisoner-of-war. It is a moment where the enemies see their shared humanity. It reminds me of Mencken's words: "Is a young man bound to serve his country in war?...They [politicans] make all wars, but very few of them ever die in one. If it is the duty of a young man to serve his country under all circumstances then it is equally the duty of an enemy young man to serve his." And this is the pitiful stupidity and paradox of war- that innocents are expended as the consequence of the folly's of cowardly men.
The film’s score supplements the action perfectly. It is unobtrusive and somehow inevitable. You can discern the fate of then men at Iwo Jima listening to it. There is a particularly stirring scene when Kuribayashi hears a song sung by children in his hometown over the radio transmittor, encouraging the tired and starving Japanese soldiers at Iwo Jima. It recalls the soldiers as to who the sacrifice is being made for. It is a travesty that Japanese children today are not enlightened about the depth of Japanese involvement in World War II. It is mostly because of the cavalcade of war crimes perpetrated by the Japanese in their occupied territories. But in whitewashing that critical episode from history, they miss the tales of inspiration and pride of which Iwo Jima is possibly only one. Those men of Iwo Jima deserve better.
For all of Japan's history, from the Paleolithic period to the Taisho period, it has never suffered under the oppression of foreign occupation. No foreign army had ever stepped foot on Japanese territory without the consent of its government until the Allies did in 1945. But for the Japanese men who were unfortunate enough to find themselves in Iwo Jima, it was not a matter of merely nationalism and history. It was about giving their families on the one more day of peace against the American onslaught that was making its way towards the Japanese Mainland.
They gave Japanese civilians thirty-six extra days. The sacrifice of those men at Iwo Jima, on both sides, is a moment to remember and as humanity, be proud of. In a moment of war, that coarsest of human endeavours, there was still valour and virtue, no matter how tragic its results were.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



